Everyone is entitled to have their view. That’s not the issue. It is about how that view is expressed and the impact that it causes.
I have already lost contact with one developer due to the negativity expressed around their work in the comments here, and I can’t say that I blame them either. Who would want to work with a site where your applications are constantly attacked, and the knock on effect to Palm Sounds.
I don’t want this site to be the place that developers avoid because all they get is people telling them where they’ve failed.
I don’t want to have to turn off comments or get to the point where I have to police and delete comments, so if you want to comment in a reasonable way and can make you point without condemning someone’s work, please continue to do so.
However, if all you want to do is tell people how much they’ve failed because they haven’t delivered the feature request you wanted, then do it somewhere else.